Saltar al contenido
Swift Agent Sites

Este artículo está disponible solo en inglés.

How to Grieve a New York Property Assessment Before Grievance Day

James Brazil vive en Mérida, México. Fundó Swift Agent Sites y estudió Clásicas en la Universidad de Mississippi.

Publicado el · Actualizado el

Bienes raíces para compradores · Bienes raíces para vendedores

A house with a yard, illustrating a New York property assessment a homeowner can grieve
Photo by Avi Werde on Unsplash

If you think your New York assessment is too high, you file Form RP-524 with the assessor or the board of assessment review by Grievance Day. In most towns that day is the fourth Tuesday in May. Miss it and you lose administrative review and the court option for this year.

You can grieve only the assessment on the current tentative roll. Prior years are closed. STAR is a different filing. It does not replace the grievance.

What day is the deadline where I live?

The Department of Taxation and Finance says Grievance Day is the fourth Tuesday in May in most communities, and you should confirm the date with your assessor or clerk. The exceptions are large enough to check:

  • New York City: class one complaints by March 15, other property by March 1, filed with the Assessment Review Commission.
  • Nassau County: March 1, also with an assessment review commission.
  • Suffolk County towns: third Tuesday in May.
  • Westchester County towns: third Tuesday in June.
  • Villages that assess: often the third Tuesday in February. Confirm with the village assessor.
  • Cities, and towns that share an assessor, can use a different day. Some shared-assessor towns may pick a day between the fourth Tuesday in May and the second Tuesday in June.

If you mail RP-524, the assessor or the board must receive it by Grievance Day. A postmark on the deadline is not the rule the department states.

What am I allowed to challenge?

The current tentative assessment. The department's calendar puts Tentative Roll Date at May 1 in most communities. The roll has to be available within ten days, including on the municipal website. Check it before Grievance Day, not after the school bill arrives.

Assessments reflect condition and ownership on taxable status date, and value on valuation date. A kitchen you finish in June does not change the roll you are looking at in May.

You can ask, in writing, for a list of your property, the assessed value, and the hearing time and place. That request has to be in no later than 15 days before Tentative Roll Date. The assessor must mail the information no later than five days after the tentative roll is completed.

How does a grievance differ from STAR?

STAR is a school-tax exemption or credit. A grievance says the assessment itself is wrong. New York's instructions say exemption applications go to the local assessor, not to the department, except for a specific extension form. Our guide to the STAR credit for new buyers covers registration. Filing STAR does not freeze the assessment, and grieving the assessment does not sign you up for STAR.

Buyers should still read the assessment before closing. The number on last year's tax bill can move on the next tentative roll. Sellers should know a pending grievance does not travel as a promise about next year's bill. Transfer taxes are a separate closing cost. See who pays New York transfer tax and mansion tax.

What if I do not live in the town?

A non-resident owner can ask for a hearing date after Grievance Day, and the board must set it no later than 21 days after Grievance Day. You still have to submit RP-524 on or before the regular Grievance Day. The request goes to the board or the assessor by that same day.

What happens after the board decides?

If you do not get the change you asked for, judicial review comes next. You cannot go to court without having gone through the grievance. Most homeowners use Small Claims Assessment Review. Tax certiorari in State Supreme Court is the other path, and the department says to use an attorney for that one.

The deadline is short. SCAR and tax certiorari have to be started within 30 days of the filing of the final assessment roll, or of notice of that filing, whichever is later. Final Roll Date is July 1 in most communities. Confirm both dates locally. Thirty days from the wrong Monday is a closed case.

What should I bring to the question of value?

The department does not publish a required exhibit list in the grievance overview, so ask the assessor what the board wants to see. Useful papers owners actually have:

  • The tentative roll entry for your parcel
  • Recent sales of similar houses, if you have them from a broker or the county
  • Photos of conditions the assessment does not reflect
  • A written statement of the error you are claiming

Flood disclosure and condition issues are a different form. See New York's property condition disclosure and flood questions. An assessment grievance is about the roll, not about what you must tell a buyer.

FAQ

What form do I file?

Form RP-524, Complaint on Real Property Assessment, outside New York City and Nassau County. Those two use their assessment review commissions and earlier deadlines.

Can I grieve last year's assessment?

No. Only the current tentative roll can be grieved.

Is Grievance Day the same everywhere?

No. The fourth Tuesday in May is the usual town date. New York City, Nassau, Suffolk, Westchester, many cities, and villages that assess use other dates. Ask your assessor.

Can I go to court first?

No. Judicial review, including Small Claims Assessment Review, comes after the grievance.

Does filing STAR grieve my assessment?

No. STAR is an exemption or credit. The assessment complaint is RP-524 or the city's own complaint, by Grievance Day.

Next step

Call the assessor, confirm Tentative Roll Date and Grievance Day, and read your parcel on the tentative roll. If the number is wrong, file RP-524 so it is received by that day. A licensed local agent can help you gather sales, and the assessor's office can tell you where the form goes.

Sources: NY Department of Taxation and Finance: grievance procedures, property tax calendar, contest your assessment, STAR exemption forms.

Antes de contratar: Nueva York tiene 113,738 licencias de bienes raíces activas, según el archivo de New York Department of State al 2 de noviembre de 2026. Verifica gratis la licencia de cualquier agente.

Información general para Nueva York. No es una predicción de precios ni un consejo sobre ninguna propiedad específica. Confirma las reglas vigentes y las condiciones locales con el tasador local y con un agente con licencia.

Los agentes que publiquen una versión con pocos cambios en su propio dominio deben poner una etiqueta canonical que apunte a esta URL.

Agrega tu negocio al centro regional de Nueva York, gratis: Bienes raíces