Skip to content
Swift Agent Sites

North Carolina Homeowners Rates and Consent to Rate: What the 7.5% Settlement Means

James Brazil lives in Mérida, Mexico. He founded Swift Agent Sites and studied Classics at the University of Mississippi.

Published · Updated

Insurance: P&C

A stack of insurance papers on a table, like the declarations page that shows a North Carolina consent-to-rate disclosure
Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

North Carolina homeowners base rates rose an average of 7.5% on June 1, 2025 and another 7.5% on June 1, 2026 under a state settlement. Consent to rate can still put your premium above the approved manual rate, and that increase has to be disclosed in bold type on or before the declarations page.

What did the 2025 rate settlement actually do?

In January 2024 the North Carolina Rate Bureau, which represents homeowners insurers and is not part of the Department, asked for an average 42.2% increase, with proposed increases of up to 99.4% in some territories. On January 17, 2025, Insurance Commissioner Mike Causey announced a settlement that replaced that request with two smaller statewide average increases:

  • 7.5% on June 1, 2025.
  • 7.5% on June 1, 2026.
  • A maximum of 35% in any territory.
  • No new Rate Bureau request to raise rates again before June 1, 2027.

The Department said the agreement would save homeowners about $777 million over two years compared with what the companies had asked for. It also said the rates were meant to leave insurers with enough money to pay claims after recent disasters and higher reinsurance costs.

Those figures are statewide averages and territory caps for the approved base rate. Your own renewal can still move more or less than 7.5% because of your coverage, deductible, claims history, and whether consent to rate applies.

What is consent to rate?

Consent to rate, often shortened to CTR, is how an insurer charges more than the manual rate the Commissioner has approved. In North Carolina it applies to private passenger auto physical damage coverage and to residential property coverage, including homeowners and dwelling fire policies.

It used to require your signature on a form. That changed on January 1, 2019. Insurers no longer need a signed CTR form for policies effective on or after that date. Instead, they have to give you a disclosure statement whenever the premium is higher than the premium based on the approved manual rate.

The disclosure has to:

  • Appear on the declarations page, or on a separate page before the declarations page.
  • Be in at least 14-point type, or larger than the rest of the document, whichever is bigger.
  • Be bold and capitalized.

You "consent" by paying the premium. The Department's FAQ is clear that the law did not raise rates by itself, and it did not take away your ability to shop or to decline the policy. It was meant to keep people from losing coverage because a signed form never made it back to the company.

How do you tell if you're paying a consent-to-rate premium?

Look at the front of your policy. If the insurer is charging more than the approved rate, that bold, capitalized statement should be on or just before the declarations page. If you don't see it and the premium looks higher than you expected, ask the company or your agent to show you the approved manual premium next to what you were billed.

Consent to rate is not the same thing as the Rate Bureau's statewide filing. The settlement limited the approved base-rate increase. CTR is a company-by-company charge above that approved rate. You can still compare quotes, raise a deductible, or ask about credits that apply to your house.

The Department also collects and publishes aggregated residential consent-to-rate data by territory, which can help you see how common those higher rates are where you live.

What should you do at renewal?

When the renewal arrives, read the declarations page and the CTR disclosure, if there is one, before you pay. Then:

  • Compare the new premium with last year's, and ask what part is the approved rate change and what part is consent to rate.
  • Get at least one other quote, including from an agent who can check more than one company.
  • Ask whether a higher deductible, updated replacement-cost coverage, or mitigation credits would change the price.
  • If you live on the coast, confirm whether wind is in the policy or written separately, because that affects both the premium and the deductible.

A rate increase can be legal and still be worth shopping. The disclosure is there so you can see that you're being asked to pay more than the approved rate, not so you have to accept the first number you're given.

FAQ

Did every North Carolina homeowner see a 7.5% increase?

No. 7.5% was the average statewide base-rate increase in each of the two years. The settlement capped any territory at 35%. Your own bill can differ because of coverage, claims, deductibles, and consent to rate.

When can the Rate Bureau ask for another homeowners increase?

The January 17, 2025 settlement bars the Rate Bureau from seeking another increase before June 1, 2027.

Do I have to sign a consent-to-rate form?

Not for policies effective on or after January 1, 2019. The insurer has to give you a bold, capitalized disclosure on or before the declarations page, and payment of the premium is treated as consent.

Does consent to rate apply to auto liability?

The Department's CTR FAQ says the rule covers private passenger auto physical damage and residential property. Auto liability is generally outside that CTR law, with a narrow exception involving certain high limits tied to an umbrella policy.

Next step

At your next renewal, sit down with a licensed local agent and compare the approved manual premium with what you're being charged. If a consent-to-rate disclosure is on the page, ask what other companies would charge for the same coverage on your house.

Sources: N.C. Department of Insurance, January 17, 2025 homeowners rate settlement; N.C. Department of Insurance, Consent to Rate FAQs.

This is general information for North Carolina. It is not a recommendation to buy, drop, or switch a specific policy. Confirm current details with the insurer or a licensed agent who knows your situation.

Agents who publish a lightly edited version on their own domain should set a canonical tag pointing to this URL.

List your business on the North Carolina hub, free: Insurance