Pennsylvania Mine Subsidence Insurance: Why Homeowners Doesn't Cover It
James Brazil lives in Mérida, Mexico. He founded Swift Agent Sites and studied Classics at the University of Mississippi.
Published · Updated
If your Pennsylvania home sits over an old coal or clay mine, your homeowners policy almost certainly won't pay if the ground drops out from under it. The state's Department of Environmental Protection sells separate Mine Subsidence Insurance for that risk. Residential coverage runs about 27 cents per $1,000, so $150,000 of coverage costs $41.25 a year.
What is mine subsidence, and who's at risk?
DEP defines it as movement of the ground surface because underground coal or clay mine workings collapse. The state's 2021 brochure says there are coal deposits and abandoned mines in 43 of Pennsylvania's 67 counties. That's well beyond the places people think of as coal country.
Damage tends to show up as:
- foundations that crack or tilt out of level;
- cracked walls, floors and ceilings;
- doors and windows that jam;
- roofs and chimneys that crack and pull apart.
DEP says it's hard to predict if or when an abandoned mine will fail, and some collapse decades after mining ends. In bad cases the whole building has to be rebuilt.
Doesn't homeowners insurance cover ground movement?
Usually not. DEP's own page says homeowners insurance usually doesn't include mine subsidence, and that's why the state offers the coverage. Earth movement exclusions are common in standard policies. Pull out your policy and read the exclusions section, or ask your agent to point to the wording.
One distinction matters a lot here. DEP says Mine Subsidence Insurance doesn't apply to sinkholes caused by limestone weathering. Those are a different geologic problem, common in parts of central and eastern Pennsylvania. If that's your concern, ask your agent separately about what your homeowners policy does or doesn't say about sinkholes.
How do you find out if your house is over a mine?
DEP runs an interactive MSI Risk map. You enter an address, coordinates or a municipality, and it shows the mining status and whether coverage is recommended. For a deeper answer, DEP also takes site-specific requests about underground mining at a location.
Some buildings in areas with known past problems need an inspection before DEP will sell a policy. A fund representative contacts you if that's the case.
What does the policy pay for?
The coverage is narrower than a homeowners policy, so it helps to know the edges.
- Buildings. Complete buildings and buildings under construction. Each building needs its own policy, so a detached garage isn't covered by the house's policy.
- Appurtenances. Fences, retaining walls, patios, walks, driveways and in-ground pools that are attached to the land and used with the house. These are capped at 10% of your coverage amount and are only paid if the house itself is damaged in the same event.
- Incidental costs. Temporary relocation, higher utilities and living costs, lost income and security for the building. Policies created or renewed after December 11, 2013 pay between $600 and $7,000 for these, depending on the loss. That money comes out of your coverage amount, not on top of it.
- Mine water blowouts. Damage from ground movement caused by a sudden discharge of water from an abandoned mine.
Contents aren't covered. DEP notes that personal belongings usually aren't damaged and can be recovered.
How much coverage should you buy, and what does it cost?
Coverage runs from $5,000 to $1,000,000. DEP's advice is to insure your home for its replacement value plus 20%, which leaves room for appurtenances and incidental costs inside the limit.
On price, DEP's numbers are about 27 cents per $1,000 of residential coverage, with $150,000 of coverage at $41.25 a year. Homeowners 65 or older by the premium due date get 10% off on their primary residence, plus 10% off policies for outbuildings at that address.
DEP says the program has paid over $47 million in homeowner claims since 1961. Claim payments are based on the actual cost to repair or replace covered damage, capped at the coverage amount or the building's replacement cost, whichever is less.
When should a buyer apply?
Earlier than you'd think. DEP says to apply when you have an agreement to purchase or when you make your mortgage application. Coverage becomes effective at closing, as long as a required inspection doesn't turn up damage that needs fixing.
Don't count on the seller's policy. DEP says the new owners can't take over an existing policy and need to apply for their own. The seller can ask for a refund of unused premium. If they notify DEP within 30 days of the sale, the refund goes back to the closing date.
If you escrow insurance, forward the MSI bill to your lender. DEP doesn't bill lenders directly.
For other coverage your homeowners policy may leave out, see flood insurance in Pennsylvania.
FAQ
How much does mine subsidence insurance cost in Pennsylvania?
DEP says residential coverage costs about 27 cents per $1,000, and $150,000 of coverage costs $41.25 a year.
Does mine subsidence insurance cover sinkholes?
Only those caused by collapsing coal or clay mines. DEP says it doesn't apply to sinkholes from limestone weathering.
Is my detached garage covered?
No. Each building needs its own policy, so a detached garage needs a separate one.
Can I transfer my policy to the person buying my house?
No. The buyer has to apply for a new policy, and you can ask DEP to refund your unused premium.
Who do I call to file a claim?
DEP's claims line is 1-800-922-1678. Billing questions go to 1-888-357-2674.
Next step
Look up your address on DEP's MSI Risk map, then ask a licensed local agent to read your homeowners exclusions with you. If the map recommends coverage, your agent can help you apply and size the limit at replacement value plus 20%.
Sources: Pennsylvania DEP, Mine Subsidence Insurance; DEP Mine Subsidence Insurance brochure (2021).
This is general information for Pennsylvania. It is not a recommendation to buy, drop, or switch a specific policy. Confirm current details with the insurer or a licensed agent who knows your situation.
Agents who publish a lightly edited version on their own domain should set a canonical tag pointing to this URL.
List your business on the Pennsylvania hub, free: Insurance