Skip to content
Swift Agent Sites

Limited Tort vs Full Tort in Pennsylvania: What You Give Up

James Brazil lives in Mérida, Mexico. He founded Swift Agent Sites and studied Classics at the University of Mississippi.

Published · Updated

Insurance: P&C

Paperwork and a pen on a desk while comparing Pennsylvania limited tort and full tort options
Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

In Pennsylvania, limited tort lowers your car insurance premium, but you and your household give up the right to sue another driver for pain and suffering unless the injury is serious or a legal exception applies. Full tort costs more and keeps that right with no restriction. You still recover medical bills and other out-of-pocket losses under either one.

What does limited tort actually take away?

The difference is about two kinds of damages.

  • Economic loss. Medical bills, lost wages and other out-of-pocket costs. Under 75 Pa.C.S. 1705, you can seek these from an at-fault driver under either option.
  • Noneconomic loss. Pain and suffering and other "nonmonetary" damages. With limited tort, you can't sue for these unless the injury is a "serious injury" or an exception applies.

Pennsylvania's motor vehicle law defines serious injury as a personal injury resulting in death, serious impairment of body function, or permanent serious disfigurement. Whether a particular injury meets that bar is often the fight in a limited tort case. That uncertainty is the real cost of the cheaper option, and it's a cost you only find out about after a crash.

What happens if you never pick one?

You get full tort. The law is very specific about this.

  • Your insurer has to send you a notice describing both options, with the premium for each.
  • If you don't respond within 20 days, the insurer sends a second and final notice.
  • If you still haven't responded 10 days before the renewal date, you're conclusively presumed to have chosen full tort.

So if you want limited tort, you have to sign and return the form. Doing nothing means paying the full tort premium.

There's one twist. If you own a registered private passenger car and you don't have insurance on it, the law says you're deemed to have chosen limited tort. Letting coverage lapse doesn't only risk your registration. It can also cut your right to sue.

When does a limited tort driver keep full tort rights?

The statute lists exceptions. If one applies, you can recover as if you'd chosen full tort without having to prove a serious injury.

You keep full tort rights against the at-fault person when that person:

  • is convicted, or accepts Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition (ARD), for driving under the influence in that accident;
  • is driving a vehicle registered in another state;
  • intended to injure himself or another person;
  • didn't have the required insurance.

You also keep full tort rights:

  • against a business that designed, made, repaired or serviced the vehicle, for a defect it caused or didn't fix;
  • if you were hurt while riding in something other than a private passenger vehicle, such as a bus or a commercial vehicle.

These exceptions are narrow. Most fender-benders involve an insured, sober, Pennsylvania-registered driver, which means none of them help.

Who in your household does your choice cover?

More people than you might think. The option the named insured picks applies to everyone insured under that policy who isn't a named insured on a different car policy. In the statute, that means a spouse or other relative living in your household, or a minor in your or a relative's custody.

If two named insureds share a policy, either one can make the tort choice for both. And when someone is covered by two policies with conflicting choices, the law uses the policy on the car they were riding in if they're insured on it, and full tort otherwise.

If you're a teenager's parent, this matters. Their right to sue for pain and suffering after a crash is tied to a form you signed.

Can an insurer punish you for choosing full tort?

No. Section 1705(e) says no insurer can cancel, refuse to write or refuse to renew a policy based on your tort election. Doing so counts as a violation of Pennsylvania's auto insurance policy law.

How do you switch from one to the other?

Your election stays in force through renewals and replacement policies with the same insurer until the company receives a signed form electing the other option. Call your agent or company and ask for the tort election form, sign it, and keep a copy. Then check your next declarations page, which should list the tort option you're on.

A practical way to decide: ask for both premiums side by side. The Insurance Department says limited tort offers significant savings, but the size of that saving varies. If the gap is small, many people decide full tort is worth it. If money's tight, limited tort may be the right call, as long as you understand the trade.

Your tort choice works alongside your liability limits and medical benefits. For those numbers, see Pennsylvania car insurance minimums.

FAQ

Is full tort the default in Pennsylvania?

Yes. If you don't sign and return the limited tort election, the law presumes you chose full tort and you're charged the full tort premium.

Can I still get my medical bills paid with limited tort?

Yes. Limited tort keeps your right to recover medical and other out-of-pocket expenses. It limits claims for pain and suffering.

What counts as a serious injury?

Pennsylvania defines it as a personal injury resulting in death, serious impairment of body function, or permanent serious disfigurement.

Does limited tort apply if a drunk driver hits me?

If the at-fault driver is convicted of or accepts ARD for DUI in that accident, you can recover as if you had full tort.

What if I drive without insurance?

An owner of a registered private passenger car without the required insurance is deemed to have chosen limited tort.

Next step

Ask a licensed local agent to quote your policy both ways and show you the dollar difference. Then decide with your household, since your choice applies to the relatives living with you.

Sources: 75 Pa.C.S. 1705, Election of tort options; 75 Pa.C.S. 1702, Definitions; Pennsylvania Insurance Department, Automobile Insurance Guide.

This is general information for Pennsylvania. It is not a recommendation to buy, drop, or switch a specific policy. Confirm current details with the insurer or a licensed agent who knows your situation.

Agents who publish a lightly edited version on their own domain should set a canonical tag pointing to this URL.

List your business on the Pennsylvania hub, free: Insurance