Ohio FAIR Plan: Home Insurance After Two Companies Say No
James Brazil lives in Mérida, Mexico. He founded Swift Agent Sites and studied Classics at the University of Mississippi.
Published · Updated
The Ohio FAIR Plan Underwriting Association is the state's insurer of last resort for homes. To apply, you generally need to have been turned down for the coverage you want by at least two insurance companies. It offers homeowners, condo and renters forms, but it still inspects and can decline homes with hazards, unrepaired damage or code violations.
What is the Ohio FAIR Plan?
It's an association that all property insurers licensed in Ohio support, set up under state law so that people with insurable property can get basic coverage when the regular market won't sell it. It isn't a government agency, and it isn't meant to be cheap. Think of it as a backstop while you fix whatever made other companies say no.
Its office is in Columbus, at 8800 Lyra Drive, and the main number is 614-839-6446.
Who qualifies?
The FAIR Plan lists its underwriting rules for each type of policy. The big ones for a homeowner are:
- You've been denied the coverage you're seeking by at least two insurance companies.
- The home is a one to four family dwelling that you own and live in as your primary residence, with at least half of it occupied.
- It isn't a farm, a commercial property, or under construction.
- It isn't in foreclosure, litigation or receivership.
- There's no unrepaired damage or unsettled loss.
- Property taxes and assessments aren't delinquent.
- It doesn't violate building, housing, health, fire or safety codes.
Seasonal homes can qualify for the most basic form, but only if they're identified as seasonal, aren't rented, aren't for sale and aren't vacant.
What policy types does it sell?
The FAIR Plan offers four standard forms you'll recognize from the regular market:
- HO 0008. A basic, named-perils form often used for older homes. It covers fire, lightning, wind, hail, explosion, riot, plus extended perils like vehicle and aircraft damage, smoke, vandalism and sinkhole collapse. Theft is capped at $1,000 or $5,000, and the dwelling has to be insured for at least $15,000.
- HO 0003. Broader coverage for the house itself, which is covered for everything that isn't excluded. Your belongings are covered for named perils. The dwelling limit must be at least $25,000 and at least half of replacement cost.
- HO 0006. For condo owners, with dwelling coverage of at least $5,000 and personal property of at least $10,000.
- HO 0004. For renters, with at least $5,000 in personal property coverage.
Personal liability comes in $100,000 or $300,000 limits, and medical payments to others is capped at $1,000.
What property conditions can still get you declined?
This is the part that surprises people. The FAIR Plan is the last resort, but it still has standards, and some of them are very specific:
- Handrails on all stairs with more than three steps, and on porches.
- A full fence around an in-ground pool, and a gate on an above-ground pool.
- A fence or barrier around a hot tub or trampoline.
- No aggressive dogs, including pit bulls and pit bull mixes, unless canine liability is excluded by endorsement.
- No loss-producing hazards or deficiencies, which usually means things like a failing roof, exposed wiring or heavy debris.
- Any problems from a prior FAIR Plan policy have to be fully resolved.
Many of these are cheap to fix. A railing on the back steps can be the difference between coverage and a denial letter.
Should the FAIR Plan be your long-term answer?
Usually not. It's a way to stay insured, which matters a lot if you have a mortgage, since lenders require coverage and will buy expensive force-placed insurance if you let it lapse. But the coverage is often narrower than a regular policy, especially the HO 0008 form, and the theft and liability limits are modest.
A better plan is to use the FAIR Plan as a bridge:
- Ask each company that declined you for the specific reason.
- Fix what you can, whether it's a roof, wiring, railings or a dog liability issue.
- Keep receipts and photos of the repairs.
- Ask an agent to shop the regular market again at your next renewal.
What about flood?
None of these forms cover flood. If you're near a river, creek or Lake Erie, ask about a separate National Flood Insurance Program policy. NFIP policies generally have a 30-day waiting period before they take effect, so don't wait for a storm forecast.
FAQ
How do I qualify for the Ohio FAIR Plan?
You generally need to have been denied the coverage you want by at least two insurers, and the home has to meet the plan's underwriting rules, including owner occupancy and no unrepaired damage or code violations.
Does the Ohio FAIR Plan cover renters and condos?
Yes. It offers the HO 0004 renters form and the HO 0006 condo form, along with HO 0003 and HO 0008 homeowners forms.
Can the Ohio FAIR Plan deny my home?
Yes. It can decline properties that don't meet its standards, such as missing handrails, unfenced pools, aggressive dogs, delinquent taxes or unrepaired damage.
Is the FAIR Plan the same as flood insurance?
No. FAIR Plan policies don't cover flood. That requires a separate flood policy.
Next step
Before you apply, ask a licensed local agent to try the regular market one more time and tell you exactly why companies are declining. If the FAIR Plan is the only option, have them walk through the form you're offered so you know where the coverage is thinner than a standard policy.
Sources: Ohio FAIR Plan, Homeowners Coverage and underwriting criteria; Ohio Revised Code 3929.44; FloodSmart, National Flood Insurance Program.
This is general information for Ohio. It is not a recommendation to buy, drop, or switch a specific policy. Confirm current details with the insurer or a licensed agent who knows your situation.
Agents who publish a lightly edited version on their own domain should set a canonical tag pointing to this URL.
List your business on the Ohio hub, free: Insurance