How to File a Wisconsin Insurance Complaint With the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance
James Brazil lives in Mérida, Mexico. He founded Swift Agent Sites and studied Classics at the University of Mississippi.
Published · Updated
If you have a problem with a Wisconsin insurance company or agent, contact the company or the agent first. If that does not resolve it, you can file a complaint with the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance online, by mail, by email, or by phone.
OCI is the state office that regulates insurers and can review consumer complaints. A complaint does not replace a lawsuit or a claims appraisal, but it is the official consumer path when a company or agent will not address a billing, claims, or service issue.
What should you try before you file?
OCI's consumer materials on terminations and cancellations, and its contact page, start with a practical step: talk with the company or the agent first. Ask for a supervisor if the first person you reach cannot help. Keep notes of the date, the person's name or department, and what you were told. Put a follow-up request in writing when the issue involves a denial, a cancellation, a nonrenewal, a premium dispute, or a claim payment.
Have these items ready before you file, because OCI's complaint intake will go faster if the facts are in one place:
- Your name, mailing address, phone number, and email address
- The policy number, claim number, and the name of the insurance company and the agent, if any
- Dates of the event, the claim, the notice, or the billing problem
- Copies of the declarations page, the denial or cancellation letter, estimates, photos, and your written requests to the company
- A short, factual summary of what happened and what you want the company to do
Do not send original titles, original policies, or original photographs if a copy will do. Keep a copy of everything you send.
How do you file with OCI?
OCI accepts complaints online and on a printed form. You can also call or email. Official contact details published by OCI include:
- Phone (Madison): (608) 266-0103
- Phone (statewide): (800) 236-8517
- Email: ocicomplaints@wisconsin.gov (include your name, phone number, and email address)
- Mail: Office of the Commissioner of Insurance, P.O. Box 7873, Madison, WI 53707-7873
- Street: 101 East Wilson St., Madison, WI 53703
OCI's public footer also lists (608) 266-3585. If a recorded menu or a form points you to one number over another, use the contact path on the current OCI contact page so your complaint reaches the complaints unit.
When you email, include your name, a phone number, and an email address, as OCI requests. When you mail a form, use the post office box unless a current form asks for a different address. The street address is useful if you are delivering a document in person, but confirm hours and any appointment rule before you travel.
A complaint can cover auto, home, life, health, and other lines that OCI regulates. If the issue is a midterm cancellation, a nonrenewal, or a notice that looks short, bring the notice and the policy effective dates. Wisconsin's cancellation and nonrenewal timing rules, including a 10-day midterm notice and a 60-day nonrenewal notice, are set in state law and explained in OCI publication PI-024. Those timing rules are a common subject of consumer complaints and are covered in a companion article.
OCI can review whether the company followed insurance law and can ask the company for a response. It cannot always order a company to pay a disputed claim the way a court can, and it does not replace your policy's appraisal, arbitration, or appeal language. If a deadline to sue or to demand appraisal is running, a complaint does not automatically pause that deadline. A licensed local agent or an attorney can help you track those policy deadlines while the complaint is pending.
If the complaint involves a cancelled or nonrenewed policy, attach the notice and a copy of the declarations page that shows the effective dates. Timing questions are easier to review when the mailed or delivered date is in the file. If you have already written to the company, include that letter and any response you received.
If the company is not licensed in Wisconsin, or the seller is not an insurance company, OCI may tell you that another office has jurisdiction. In that case, follow the referral and keep your records.
FAQ
Do I have to contact the insurance company before I file with OCI?
OCI's consumer materials ask you to contact the company or agent first. If that does not resolve the issue, file with OCI and include what you already tried.
What phone numbers does OCI publish for complaints?
OCI lists (608) 266-0103 in Madison and (800) 236-8517 statewide. Its public footer also lists (608) 266-3585. Use the current contact page if you are unsure which number to call.
Where do I mail a complaint?
Mail the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance, P.O. Box 7873, Madison, WI 53707-7873. The street address is 101 East Wilson St., Madison, WI 53703.
What should I include in an email complaint?
OCI asks you to include your name, phone number, and email address. Add the company name, policy or claim number, and a clear summary of the problem, and keep a copy of what you sent.
If a claim denial, a cancellation, or a billing dispute is still unresolved after you contacted the company, talk with a licensed local agent about the policy and, if needed, file with OCI using the official contacts above.
Sources: Office of the Commissioner of Insurance, Contact OCI; Office of the Commissioner of Insurance, Terminations and Cancellations (PI-024).
This is general information for Wisconsin. It is not a recommendation to buy, drop, or switch a specific policy. Confirm current details with the insurer or a licensed agent who knows your situation.
Agents who publish a lightly edited version on their own domain should set a canonical tag pointing to this URL.
List your business on the Wisconsin hub, free: Insurance