New York Moving Scams: Red Flags and Where to Complain
James Brazil lives in Mérida, Mexico. He founded Swift Agent Sites and studied Classics at the University of Mississippi.
Published · Updated
The biggest New York moving scam red flags are a mover that can't give you a NYSDOT certificate number, a quote given without asking what you own, a price far below everyone else, and a demand for a big payment upfront. Check the license with NYSDOT first. If it goes wrong, complain to the state.
This isn't rare. In a 2025 consumer alert, the New York Department of State cited Better Business Bureau figures for 2024: more than 100,000 inquiries about moving companies and 718 complaints against movers, with a median loss of $754.
What are the red flags of a moving scam?
From NYSDOT and the Department of State's Division of Consumer Protection:
- No certificate number. Licensed movers must show their name, NYSDOT certificate number, and address in ads. NYSDOT says to be wary of a mover that gives you only a phone number
- Instant quotes. A price over the phone or by email without questions about how much you're moving
- Lowball bids. NYSDOT's booklet warns about exceptionally low estimates
- Big deposits. The Department of State says reputable movers generally don't need significant advances, so be wary of large upfront or full payments
- Blank forms. Any request to sign an estimate or contract with empty spaces
- No physical address. The company should have a real address, detailed contact info, and decent reviews
- No confirmation. Reputable companies confirm before move day with the crew's names and direct numbers
Any one of these is a reason to slow down. Two or more, walk away.
What are the most common moving scams?
The Department of State describes three:
- Bait and switch. A low quote up front, then last-minute price changes. On a binding estimate, you can't be made to pay more than the agreed amount unless you asked for extra services after
- No-show. You pay a deposit or the full price, and the movers never come
- Hostage goods. The mover holds your things until you pay more money
It also lists late deliveries without notice, damaged or missing items, and failing to do what the contract says as deceptive practices to watch for.
Can a New York mover hold my belongings?
A licensed mover can hold your shipment until you pay the maximum amount listed on the order for service, in cash, certified check, or money order unless you arranged credit. That's the rule in NYSDOT's model tariff.
What it can't do is keep demanding more. NYSDOT limits how much over the estimate is due on delivery, and you get 15 days to pay any balance above that. On a binding estimate dispute, the mover must release everything once you pay the binding amount plus 10%. Our guide to New York hourly moves vs binding estimates explains those limits.
If a mover is asking for a lot more than the order for service says, that's a problem to report.
How do I protect myself before the move?
The Department of State and NYSDOT recommend:
- Verify the license with NYSDOT at 518-457-6512 or nymoving@dot.ny.gov, using the exact company name and NYDOT number
- Get estimates from at least three companies
- Pay by credit card when you can, so you can dispute charges
- Never sign blank or incomplete forms. Write "N/A" and draw a line through empty spaces
- Make a photo record and written inventory of your things
- Meet the company rep at your home before loading to review the cost and delivery terms
- Insist on NYSDOT's Summary of Information booklet, which explains your rights
A quick mover check can help you screen names, but confirm with NYSDOT before you pay a deposit. For the full hiring process, see how to hire a NYSDOT-licensed mover.
What if my things are lost or damaged?
Start with the mover, in writing, as soon as you can. Two NYSDOT documents set different clocks, and this page does not treat one as a repeal of the other.
17 NYCRR 814.8 says:
- The mover must acknowledge your written claim within 30 days
- It must pay, decline, adjust, or make a firm written offer within 90 days
- If it cannot finish in 90 days, it has to update you in writing every 30 days and copy NYSDOT
The November 2025 Summary of Information for Shippers of Household Goods, and the Department's moving page, instead say the mover must pay, decline, or make a firm compromise offer within 120 days after receiving the claim. The 90 days in that booklet is the time to file, unless circumstances are unusual. See how to hire a NYSDOT-licensed mover for both clocks side by side.
Keep proof. NYSDOT says the best evidence is notes on the shipping papers made at delivery. And the delivery receipt can't include language that releases the mover from liability, beyond noting that goods arrived in apparent good condition except as marked.
Where do I file a complaint in New York?
It depends on the move and the problem. The Department of State lays it out:
- Loss or damage on a move within New York. After trying the company in writing, file with the Department of State's Division of Consumer Protection. Its helpline is 1-800-697-1220, Monday to Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
- Other disputes on a move within New York. File with NYSDOT, using its household goods mover consumer complaint form
- Interstate moves. File with FMCSA's National Consumer Complaint Database
Moving out of state? Federal rules apply. See moving out of New York.
What about storage?
Storage has its own rules. The Department of State says self-storage agreements must spell out where your things are kept, the monthly cost including fees, and the facility's liability. If you fall behind, the facility has to send an itemized notice with the amount due and the sale date before selling your things. Active-duty service members' belongings can't be sold for nonpayment.
FAQ
How do I know if a New York mover is licensed?
Call NYSDOT at 518-457-6512 or email nymoving@dot.ny.gov with the company's exact name and NYDOT number.
Is a big deposit a red flag?
It can be. The Department of State says reputable movers generally don't require significant advances.
Where do I complain about a New York mover?
Loss or damage on an in-state move goes to the Department of State's Division of Consumer Protection. Other in-state disputes go to NYSDOT. Interstate moves go to FMCSA.
How long does a mover have to answer my claim?
Regulation 17 NYCRR 814.8 says 30 days to acknowledge and 90 days to pay, decline, adjust, or offer, then a status letter every 30 days if the claim stays open. The November 2025 shipper booklet says 120 days for that pay, decline, or offer. The two documents do not match.
Next step
If you're moving because you bought or sold a home, a licensed local real estate agent can share mover names past clients have used. Check every name with NYSDOT before you book. More guides are on the New York movers page.
Sources: NYS Department of State: Tips to avoid moving scams (2025), NYS Department of State: Moving and storage scams guide (2023), 17 NYCRR 814.8, claims for loss, damage or overcharge, NYSDOT: Summary of Information for Shippers of Household Goods, revised November 2025, NYSDOT: The Mover's Guide to Transporting Household Goods in New York State (PDF), NYSDOT: Household goods mover consumer complaint form (PDF).
Before you hire: Check a moving company's federal authority and insurance free, from FMCSA's records.
General notes for moves in and out of New York. Not a quote or a recommendation of any specific company. Confirm details with the mover you hire.
Agents who publish a lightly edited version on their own domain should set a canonical tag pointing to this URL.
List your business on the New York hub, free: Transportation