New York's FAIR Plan (NYPIUA): How It Works
James Brazil lives in Mérida, Mexico. He founded Swift Agent Sites and studied Classics at the University of Mississippi.
Published · Updated
The New York Property Insurance Underwriting Association (NYPIUA) is the state's insurer of last resort for property coverage. It's an association of every insurer that sells fire insurance in New York. If no regular company will write your home, NYPIUA can, but its policies leave out liability, theft, and flood, so most owners need extra coverage around it.
DFS is clear that NYPIUA is a fallback. Its coverage is limited and costs more than the regular market, and DFS says you and your agent or broker "should make every effort" to place the policy with a voluntary insurer first. Still, if you've been turned down or dropped, it's good to know how it works.
What is NYPIUA?
NYPIUA is New York's version of what other states call a FAIR Plan. It's set up under Article 54 of the Insurance Law, and every company selling fire insurance in New York is a member.
It writes:
- Dwelling and commercial buildings
- Contents of commercial premises
- Household furnishings and personal property
Most people hear about it from their agent after a declination or a non-renewal. If that just happened to you, read up on New York's non-renewal rules too. The notice itself has to follow the law.
What does a NYPIUA policy cover?
DFS describes two forms.
The Basic form covers fire and extended coverage, which includes:
- Wind, including hurricane, and hail
- Explosion (except steam boilers), riot, and civil commotion
- Aircraft, vehicles, and smoke
- Vandalism and malicious mischief
The Broad Form costs more and adds:
- Damage by burglars (but not theft of your property)
- Falling objects and the weight of ice, snow, or sleet
- Accidental discharge of water or steam
- Sudden cracking of a steam or hot water heating system
- Freezing
- Sudden damage from artificial electric currents
Broad Form policies in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Nassau, Queens, Staten Island, Suffolk, and Westchester carry a 2% hurricane deductible, according to DFS. It kicks in for a Category 2 or stronger hurricane that makes landfall in New York. Our guide to New York hurricane deductibles explains how those work.
What doesn't it cover?
This is the part people miss. NYPIUA policies don't include:
- Liability. If a guest gets hurt on your steps, NYPIUA won't defend you
- Theft. Burglar damage to the house is covered on Broad Form, but stolen stuff isn't
- Flood. That's a separate policy, usually through the NFIP. See does homeowners insurance cover flooding in New York
NYPIUA policies are also generally written on an actual cash value basis. That means depreciation comes off a claim. An old roof won't pay out like a new one.
How high do the limits go?
NYPIUA publishes its limits. For one- to four-family private homes that are occupied:
- $600,000 per location for the building
- $250,000 for household and personal property, plus additional living expense
- $50,000 for rental value per location
For vacant or unoccupied homes, the building limit drops to $100,000. If your home would cost more than $600,000 to rebuild, ask your agent how to cover the gap.
Who isn't eligible?
NYPIUA lists conditions that make a building or owner ineligible. A few that come up most:
- Vacant buildings that don't meet its boarding standards or have no intrusion alarm
- Signs of poor upkeep, unsafe heating or wiring, or unsafe or illegal occupancy
- Property taxes or utility bills two or more years behind
- Damage to walls, floors, or roofs that isn't being actively repaired
- Outstanding code violations that affect occupancy
- Two or more losses in three years from conditions the owner could control, with no fix
- Owners convicted of arson or insurance fraud, or who owe NYPIUA an uncontested premium
If one of these applies, fixing it first is usually faster than arguing it.
What is C-MAP?
The Coastal Market Assistance Program (C-MAP) is a voluntary network of insurers and agents that NYPIUA runs for coastal homeowners. It's how a lot of shoreline owners end up with something close to a regular homeowners policy.
DFS says C-MAP is for owner-occupied one- to four-family homes, apartment units, and condo units in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Nassau, Queens, Staten Island, Suffolk, and Westchester. Distance from the water matters:
- Long Island's south shore and forks, Brooklyn, Queens, and Staten Island: generally within one mile of the shore
- Long Island's north shore, the Bronx, and Westchester: generally within 2,500 feet of the shore
Before applying, you must have gotten a non-renewal, cancellation, or conditional non-renewal notice from your insurer for a reason other than nonpayment. New buyers have to name the prior owner's insurer.
The setup pairs a NYPIUA Basic or Broad Form policy with a "wrap-around" policy from a participating insurer. The wrap-around adds liability, personal property, theft, and other coverage. DFS says that pairing can also get you replacement cost on the building instead of actual cash value. You can reach NYPIUA about C-MAP at (212) 208-9700.
Are there other options?
One more. DFS says you can buy homeowners coverage from an excess line insurer through a specially licensed excess line broker, but only after at least three licensed insurers have declined you.
Read those policies closely. Excess line insurers skip New York's rate and form filing rules, so coverage and deductibles can differ. And if an excess line insurer goes under, you're not protected by the state's Property/Casualty Insurance Security Fund.
FAQ
Is NYPIUA the same as a FAIR Plan?
It plays the same role. NYPIUA is an association of all insurers selling fire insurance in New York, and it writes property coverage when the regular market won't.
Does NYPIUA include liability coverage?
No. DFS says NYPIUA policies don't include liability, flood, or theft coverage.
What's the most NYPIUA will insure a house for?
For an occupied one- to four-family home, its published limit is $600,000 per location for the building.
Who can use C-MAP?
Owner-occupied coastal homes, apartment units, and condo units in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Nassau, Queens, Staten Island, Suffolk, and Westchester that got a non-renewal or cancellation for a reason other than nonpayment.
Next step
A licensed local insurance agent or broker can shop the regular market one more time, then price a NYPIUA policy with a wrap-around or separate liability coverage if you need it. Bring your declination or non-renewal letter and your current declarations page. More guides are on the New York insurance page.
Sources: DFS: Problems Obtaining Insurance, NYPIUA: Product Information.
This is general information for New York. It is not a recommendation to buy, drop, or switch a specific policy. Confirm current details with the insurer or a licensed agent who knows your situation.
Agents who publish a lightly edited version on their own domain should set a canonical tag pointing to this URL.
List your business on the New York hub, free: Insurance