Skip to content
Swift Agent Sites

Indiana Auto Policy Cancellations, 20-Day Nonrenewal Notice, and the Auto Insurance Plan

James Brazil lives in Mérida, Mexico. He founded Swift Agent Sites and studied Classics at the University of Mississippi.

Published · Updated

Insurance: P&C

Clouds filling the sky, a reminder to read an Indiana auto cancellation or nonrenewal notice before coverage ends
Photo by Anandu Vinod on Unsplash

After an Indiana auto policy has been in effect 60 days, the company cannot cancel except for certain reasons, such as nonpayment or loss of a driver license. A nonrenewal at the end of the policy period requires 20 days' advance notice.

If you cannot find auto coverage in the regular market, you may apply to the Indiana Auto Insurance Plan through any insurance agent in the state.

What IDOI says about cancellation and nonrenewal

The Indiana Department of Insurance (IDOI) Auto Insurance page sets out the timing rules in plain language. Insurance companies may cancel your policy within the first 60 days of a new policy. After the policy has been in effect 60 days, the company cannot cancel except for certain reasons, such as your failure to pay the premium or losing your license to drive. At the end of the policy period, the company may refuse to renew, but it must give you 20 days' advance notice.

Read any cancellation or nonrenewal letter as soon as it arrives. Note the effective date, the reason, and whether the action is a midterm cancellation or a nonrenewal when the term ends. If the letter arrives late, or if the reason does not match IDOI's examples, you can ask the company in writing for an explanation and, if needed, file a written complaint with IDOI Consumer Services. A complaint does not automatically keep a cancelled policy in force, so arrange replacement coverage before the date in the letter.

Nonpayment is a common midterm reason. If a cancellation is for nonpayment, ask the company whether a payment can reinstate the policy and the exact deadline. Do not assume a late payment has restored coverage until you have written confirmation and a current identification card. Driving without 25/50/25 liability insurance remains unlawful, and the Bureau of Motor Vehicles can request a Certificate of Compliance after a crash or certain violations.

A nonrenewal is different from a midterm cancellation. The company is declining to offer another term, and IDOI says it must give 20 days' advance notice. Use that window to shop. Ask each licensed agent for quotes at the same liability limits, and confirm whether uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage will be included unless you reject it in writing. If you have had claims or a lapse, start the search early rather than waiting until the last week of the 20-day period.

When the regular market will not write the risk

IDOI asks, "Turned down by an insurance company?" and answers that you can apply for the Indiana Auto Insurance Plan through any insurance agent in Indiana. Each insurance company licensed in Indiana may participate by taking its share of the drivers who have difficulty buying insurance. The Plan is a residual auto market, not a shortcut to a cheaper preferred policy. Ask the agent what limits are available, what the premium will be, and how long the assignment lasts.

The Indiana FAIR Plan, by contrast, is a last-resort market for property insurance, not for auto liability. Do not confuse the two. If you were declined for homeowners coverage, the FAIR Plan is the property path. If you were declined for auto coverage, the Auto Insurance Plan is the path IDOI names.

Practical steps if you receive a cancellation or nonrenewal notice:

  • Confirm the date coverage ends, and do not drive uninsured after that date.
  • Ask the current company, in writing, for the reason and for any appeal or reinstatement option.
  • Shop with more than one licensed agent, including an application to the Auto Insurance Plan if admitted companies decline the risk.
  • Put the new policy in force before the old one ends, and keep both identification cards until the overlap is clear.
  • If the BMV later asks for a Certificate of Compliance, have the insurer that covered the date of the incident file it electronically.

IDOI Consumer Services can answer general questions at 800-622-4461 or 317-232-2395. Formal complaints must be in writing.

Keep written quotes, declination letters, and the Auto Insurance Plan application with your policy file. If the Plan issues a policy, read the identifications, limits, and any SR-22 or Certificate of Compliance needs with the same care you would use in the admitted market. The 25/50/25 liability minimum still applies, and uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage still must be included on a newly written Indiana auto liability policy unless a named insured rejects it in writing.

FAQ

Can my Indiana auto insurer cancel my policy at any time?

Companies may cancel within the first 60 days of a new policy. After 60 days, IDOI says the company cannot cancel except for certain reasons, such as failure to pay the premium or losing your driver license.

How much notice is required if the company will not renew?

IDOI says the company must give you 20 days' advance notice if it refuses to renew at the end of the policy period.

What if several companies decline to insure me?

IDOI says you can apply for the Indiana Auto Insurance Plan through any insurance agent in Indiana. Licensed companies may participate by taking a share of hard-to-place drivers.

Is the Auto Insurance Plan the same as the FAIR Plan?

No. The Auto Insurance Plan is a residual market for auto coverage. The Indiana FAIR Plan is a last-resort market for property insurance.

Next step

If you have a cancellation or nonrenewal letter, ask a licensed local agent to quote replacement coverage that meets the 25/50/25 minimums before the date in the notice, and to apply to the Indiana Auto Insurance Plan if admitted companies decline the risk.

Sources: Indiana Department of Insurance, Auto Insurance; Indiana Bureau of Motor Vehicles, Proof of Financial Responsibility; Indiana Department of Insurance, File an Insurance Company Complaint.

This is general information for Indiana. It is not a recommendation to buy, drop, or switch a specific policy. Confirm current details with the insurer or a licensed agent who knows your situation.

Agents who publish a lightly edited version on their own domain should set a canonical tag pointing to this URL.

List your business on the Indiana hub, free: Insurance