Skip to content
Swift Agent Sites

Idaho's Medigap Birthday Rule: 63 Days to Switch Without Health Questions

James Brazil lives in Mérida, Mexico. He founded Swift Agent Sites and studied Classics at the University of Mississippi.

Published · Updated

Insurance: Medicare & retirement

Papers and a pen on a desk, illustrating Idaho's Medigap birthday-rule enrollment window
Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

If you already have a Medicare supplement (Medigap) policy in Idaho, you get 63 days starting on your birthday to switch to a comparable or lesser Medigap policy without medical underwriting. The rule is in IDAPA 18.04.10. It does not give that right to someone who has never had a Medigap policy.

The Idaho Department of Insurance says the change took effect for enrollments on or after March 1, 2022. Your current policy stays in force until you ask to change it.

Who can use the birthday rule?

IDAPA 18.04.10.041.02.j describes a person who is enrolled in a Medicare supplement policy and, on or after March 1, 2022, voluntarily drops it and enrolls in another Medicare supplement policy. The guaranteed-issue clock for that switch starts on the birthday and ends 63 days later.

The department's own explanation is the practical version. Policyholders may change insurance company, plan, or both, once a year, regardless of health conditions, during that 63-day period. The department's shopper materials describe the switch as equal or lesser coverage. The rule text says the policies you are entitled to are any comparable or lesser Medicare supplement policy offered by any issuer.

If you don't already have a Medigap policy, the birthday rule is the wrong door. The department says other guaranteed-issue rights might still apply, and you should ask SHIBA or a licensed agent which ones, if any, fit your situation.

How is this different from fall Open Enrollment?

Medicare's Open Enrollment, October 15 through December 7, is for Medicare Advantage and Part D drug plans. Idaho's birthday rule is a state Medigap right. They sit on different calendars, and a Medigap policy does not pair with a Medicare Advantage plan.

Your first Medigap open enrollment is still the six months that start when you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B, or when Part B starts because of disability or end-stage renal disease. During that six months, Idaho rules say an issuer can't turn you down or charge you more because of your health. Our Medicare Open Enrollment checklist walks through the fall window. Use this page for the birthday window.

What does "comparable or lesser" mean?

You are not guaranteed every letter plan on the market. The rule limits the guaranteed-issue offer to a comparable or lesser benefit package. A move from a richer plan to a thinner one fits. A move the other way may not, and the company can underwrite it.

Plans with the same letter have the same core benefits. Premiums don't. Two Plan G policies can cost different amounts. The point of the birthday window is that you can shop the price of a comparable package, including at a different company, without answering health questions.

Idaho also moved new Medigap premiums to community rating. The department says that after February 28, 2022, premium rates for new Medicare supplement policies, including a switch to a new company, are no longer based on the applicant's age. Tobacco use can still affect the price. If you are under 65, older department guidance has said issuers may charge up to 150% of the 65-year-old rate during open enrollment, and they still can't decline you in that first six-month window. Confirm the rate you are actually offered before you cancel anything.

When should I apply?

The guaranteed-issue period begins on your birthday and runs 63 days. The department's example uses a December 28 birthday and says some companies may take an application before those 63 days, but they don't have to. If your birthday is close, ask the company what effective date it will use and get the acceptance in writing before you drop the old policy.

A gap between policies is the expensive mistake. Medigap policies are guaranteed renewable, so the one you have continues until you replace it. Don't cancel the old policy on your birthday morning and hope the new application clears.

What else should I check before I switch?

  • Whether the new plan is actually comparable or lesser, in the company's words and in the outline of coverage
  • The premium, and whether it is the community rate or a tobacco rate
  • The effective date, so the old policy ends the day the new one starts
  • That you still have a Part D drug plan if the Medigap doesn't cover prescriptions, which it generally doesn't
  • That you are on Original Medicare, not a Medicare Advantage plan

Households that split the year between Idaho and another state should ask whether the new policy's coverage follows them. A Medigap policy pays after Original Medicare, so the doctor still has to take Medicare. That is a different question from a Medicare Advantage network.

FAQ

How long is Idaho's Medigap birthday window? 63 days, starting on your birthday, under IDAPA 18.04.10.

Can I switch companies, or only plans? Both. The Department of Insurance says you may change company, plan, or both. The new policy has to be a comparable or lesser Medicare supplement.

I don't have a Medigap policy. Can I buy one on my birthday? The birthday rule applies to people who already have a Medicare supplement. Ask SHIBA whether a different guaranteed-issue right applies to you.

Will the new premium depend on my age? For new policies issued under the rule, the department says rates are community rated and are not based on the applicant's age. Confirm the quote. Tobacco use can still change it.

Where do I get free help? Idaho SHIBA, at the Department of Insurance, 1-800-247-4422.

Next step

If your birthday is inside the next two months, ask a licensed agent or SHIBA to line up a comparable or lesser quote with a named effective date. Keep the policy you have until the new one is issued.

Sources: Idaho Department of Insurance: Recent changes to Medicare supplement law and rules, IDAPA 18.04.10, Medicare Supplement Insurance Standards (sections 036 and 041, including 041.02.j, 041.03.g, and 041.05.f), SHIBA contact.

This is general information for Idaho. It is not a recommendation to buy, drop, or switch a specific policy. Confirm current details with the insurer or a licensed agent who knows your situation.

Agents who publish a lightly edited version on their own domain should set a canonical tag pointing to this URL.

Agents serving this area

The Eagle Team — American Senior Benefits, Eagle Region

Medicare, long-term care, and life insurance. Office at 1036 Iron Eagle Drive, Eagle, Idaho. Serving Idaho, Oregon, and Wyoming.

Insurance agents in Eagle

List your business on the Idaho hub, free: Insurance