Skip to content
Swift Agent Sites

Michigan's FAIR Plan: Homeowners Coverage Through the Basic Property Insurance Association

James Brazil lives in Mérida, Mexico. He founded Swift Agent Sites and studied Classics at the University of Mississippi.

Published · Updated

Insurance: P&C

A snow-covered house in winter, the kind of Michigan home that may need last-resort property insurance through the FAIR Plan
Photo by Fabian Mardi on Unsplash

If you can't find homeowners insurance in Michigan's regular market, the Michigan Basic Property Insurance Association can be a last-resort option. The Association, often called the FAIR Plan or MBPIA, writes homeowners, renters, condo, dwelling fire, and commercial property coverage for qualified people and qualified property. You generally have to try the regular market first.

What is the Michigan Basic Property Insurance Association?

The Department of Insurance and Financial Services describes MBPIA as a way to provide property insurance to qualified people who cannot get it from authorized insurers. Homeowners coverage is the most common personal policy it issues. DIFS says the Association's policy forms are equivalent to the HO-2 and HO-3 forms used by authorized companies.

Policies are written for one year and can be renewed on qualified property. The pool may also issue a binder, with the right premium, for up to 60 days while remaining conditions are being met.

This is not a bargain shopper's policy and not a special discount plan. It's the state's residual market for people who otherwise may be left uninsured.

Who qualifies, and what property qualifies?

DIFS says you qualify if you own or rent and live in "qualified property." Qualified property means residential property that meets building code standards, is not used for farm or business reasons, and is not used for illegal activities.

The Insurance Code also sets conditions for basic property insurance through the pool. In general, the pool looks for:

  • An inspection of the property by the inspection bureau within the preceding six months, unless a renewal inspection is waived under the rules.
  • A good-faith, diligent effort to obtain the same type of insurance through established channels in the regular market, from authorized insurers, at a level appropriate to the property.
  • No unpaid premium on prior insurance on the property.
  • Property that is qualified and an acceptable risk under the pool's standards.

If the pool finds the property is not an acceptable risk, you are entitled to a written statement of what prevents it from qualifying and what would have to be fixed. That letter is useful. It tells you whether a repair, a cleanup, or a different occupancy will open the door.

Your agent can apply for you. Don't assume a "no" from one company is the end of the road, and don't assume the FAIR Plan will write a house that is vacant, in violation of code, or used as a business.

What's the difference between replacement cost and repair cost?

MBPIA offers both, and they are not the same.

  • A replacement cost policy is what most people mean by homeowners insurance. It lets you replace, repair, or rebuild the damaged property to its original condition with the same kind and quality of materials. To buy this from MBPIA, you must insure the property for 80% of what it would cost to replace it.
  • A repair cost policy lets you repair or rebuild to a condition similar to what it was before the damage, using modern materials. You must buy an amount of insurance equal to what the property is currently worth. DIFS notes that this type of policy generally provides less coverage for about the same cost as a replacement cost policy.

If you're comparing a FAIR Plan quote with a regular-market quote, look at the form type and the amount of insurance, not just the premium. A cheaper repair-cost policy can leave a large gap after a fire.

How does this fit with the Essential Insurance Act?

Michigan also has an Essential Insurance Act process for people who are denied auto or homeowners insurance or who believe they're being charged a premium that doesn't match approved rates. That complaint path is separate from a FAIR Plan application, and it starts with a conference with the company. If you're shopping, you can pursue a regular-market policy, use the complaint process if you were turned down incorrectly, and still apply to MBPIA if you need coverage in place.

The pool has to notify residential policyholders, before renewal, of their rights to obtain home insurance in the regular market and through the pool. If you've been in the FAIR Plan for a while, ask your agent at each renewal whether a standard company will write the house now.

FAQ

Is the Michigan FAIR Plan the same as MBPIA?

Yes. The Michigan Basic Property Insurance Association is the state's FAIR Plan, the residual market for basic property and home insurance.

Do I have to be turned down before I can apply?

You generally have to make a good-faith, diligent effort to get the same type of coverage from authorized insurers in the regular market. Your agent can help document that effort and submit the application.

Can I get a replacement cost homeowners policy from the pool?

Yes, if you qualify. You must buy insurance equal to 80% of replacement cost. The Association also offers a repair cost policy, which generally provides less coverage.

What if the pool says my house is not an acceptable risk?

You're entitled to a written statement of the problems and the steps needed to make the property acceptable. Ask for that in writing and talk with your agent about repairs or a new inspection.

Next step

If you're having trouble finding homeowners insurance, talk with a licensed local agent about a documented search of the regular market and, if needed, an application to the Michigan Basic Property Insurance Association. Ask whether a replacement cost policy is available on your house and what amount of insurance that requires.

Sources: DIFS, The Michigan Basic Property Insurance Association (FIS-PUB 0209); MCL 500.2925, application to the pool for basic property insurance; MCL 500.2925a, application to the pool for home insurance; DIFS, Essential Insurance Act complaint process.

This is general information for Michigan. It is not a recommendation to buy, drop, or switch a specific policy. Confirm current details with the insurer or a licensed agent who knows your situation.

Agents who publish a lightly edited version on their own domain should set a canonical tag pointing to this URL.

List your business on the Michigan hub, free: Insurance