If Illinois Insurers Decline You: Ask About the Automobile Insurance Plan
James Brazil lives in Mérida, Mexico. He founded Swift Agent Sites and studied Classics at the University of Mississippi.
Published · Updated
If insurance companies will not sell you a liability policy, the Illinois Secretary of State says to ask an agent about the Illinois Automobile Insurance Plan. The plan is the state-monitored route for drivers who have trouble getting coverage. Some companies will not insure an owner who has been driving uninsured.
The plan is the question to ask before you keep driving without a policy. The plan does not change the minimum. You still need at least $25,000, $50,000, and $20,000 of liability coverage, and you still have to carry the card in the vehicle.
Who is the plan for?
The Secretary of State's mandatory-insurance pamphlet describes two moments. First, if you have problems buying insurance, ask your agent about the plan. Second, if companies decline a request for vehicle insurance, ask an agent about the plan. The pamphlet calls it a state-monitored program for drivers who have difficulty obtaining insurance. It does not publish a phone number for the plan in that pamphlet, and it does not say the Secretary of State sells the policy. The path it gives you is the agent.
Bring the declination, or a note of which companies said no, to that conversation. A verbal "we do not write that" is harder to use than a letter. The Department of Insurance regulates companies, agencies, and agents. A complaint about how an application was handled is a written filing with that department. A decline by itself is the reason to ask about the plan. See how a written insurance complaint works.
What coverage still has to be on the policy?
Liability of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per crash for bodily injury, and $20,000 for property damage, is the floor under 625 ILCS 5/7-203. The shopping guide ties the duty to carry insurance to 625 ILCS 5/7-601. Trailers are not required to have liability insurance. The motor vehicle is. Uninsured-motorist coverage for bodily injury or death is included automatically at the legal minimum. Collision, comprehensive, medical payments, and uninsured property damage are not required by the state. A lender can still require physical damage on a financed car.
Those rules are the same whether the policy came from a company that wanted your business or from the plan. Read the declarations page. See the 25/50/20 minimums and what the uninsured-motorist line covers.
What happens if you drive anyway?
The pamphlet says that without coverage, a crash can mean a large loss and the loss of driving privileges. An at-fault driver who is uninsured must pay the damages or face suspension of the registration plates and the driver's license. If no officer is present, 625 ILCS 5/11-407 requires notice to local police, or to the sheriff or Illinois State Police outside a municipality, when anyone is hurt or killed or property damage is over $1,500. Property damage over $500 requires that notice when a vehicle that must be insured under 7-601 has no liability policy. The driver does not file a written report with the Department of Transportation. Section 11-406 was repealed.
The Secretary of State does not keep insurance information for every registered vehicle. Proof is the card in the car. "I applied to the plan" is not an insurance card.
What should I ask the agent?
Ask whether the application is to the Illinois Automobile Insurance Plan or to one more company in the regular market. Ask what liability limits will be on the binder, and whether uninsured-motorist injury coverage is at the minimum or higher. Ask the premium and the date coverage starts. Do not drive on a quote. Coverage starts when the company or the plan says it starts, and the card is what an officer will ask to see.
If the dispute is a premium the company already charged, or a cancellation of a policy you had, that is a complaint to the Department of Insurance after you have written the company. Consumer Assistance, for questions, is (866) 445-5364. The complaint is in writing.
What do I write down from each decline?
Keep the company name, the date, and whether the answer was a letter or a phone call. The pamphlet does not give you a state form that collects those declines. The agent is the person it tells you to ask about the plan. A list of three companies is more useful in that meeting than a general statement that insurance is hard. If one company offered a policy at the minimum and you turned it down on price, that is not the same fact as a decline. Say which it was. The mandatory-insurance division at the Secretary of State is listed on the pamphlet for questions about the law itself: 501 South Second Street, Springfield, IL 62756-7000, mandatoryinsurance@ilsos.gov. That office does not replace the agent who can submit an application.
FAQ
Does the Secretary of State sell this policy? No. The pamphlet tells you to ask an insurance agent about the Illinois Automobile Insurance Plan.
Can the plan insure me for less than 25/50/20? No. Those are the minimums for a liability policy in Illinois. The plan is a way to buy coverage, not a discount on the legal floor.
I was uninsured. Will any company take me? The pamphlet says some companies do not sell to owners who have been driving uninsured, and it points those drivers to the plan through an agent.
Is a declination letter a complaint? A decline is the reason to ask about the plan. File with the Department of Insurance if the problem is how the company handled the application, a bill, or a claim.
Does applying pause the mandatory-insurance law? No. You need a policy in force and the card in the vehicle. An application is not coverage.
Next step
Take the names of the companies that declined you to an agent and ask, in those words, about the Illinois Automobile Insurance Plan. Confirm the effective date and put the card in the car before you drive. If a company you already have is the problem, write that company before you write the department.
Sources: Illinois Secretary of State: Mandatory Vehicle Insurance (VSD 361), Illinois Department of Insurance: auto insurance shopping guide, 625 ILCS 5/11-407.
This is general information for Illinois. It is not a recommendation to buy, drop, or switch a specific policy. Confirm current details with the insurer or a licensed agent who knows your situation.
Agents who publish a lightly edited version on their own domain should set a canonical tag pointing to this URL.
List your business on the Illinois hub, free: Insurance