Georgia's 60-Day Bad-Faith Law for Delayed Insurance Claims
James Brazil lives in Mérida, Mexico. He founded Swift Agent Sites and studied Classics at the University of Mississippi.
Published · Updated
Under Georgia law, if your insurer refuses to pay a covered loss within 60 days after you demand payment, and that refusal is in bad faith, it can owe you a penalty. The penalty is up to 50% of what it owes or $5,000, whichever is greater, plus reasonable attorney's fees. The demand and the timing matter a lot.
What does Georgia's bad-faith statute cover?
O.C.G.A. 33-4-6 applies to first-party claims, meaning claims you make on your own policy. Think home, auto physical damage, renters or business property. The basic rule has four parts:
- The loss has to be covered by the policy.
- You have to make a demand for payment.
- The insurer has to refuse to pay within 60 days after that demand.
- A judge or jury has to find the refusal was in bad faith.
If all four are met, the insurer owes the amount of the loss plus the penalty and your reasonable attorney's fees. If the insurer pays after the 60 days are up, that doesn't wipe out the bad-faith claim.
What counts as a proper demand?
Georgia courts have set some practical rules about demands:
- Timing matters. The demand has to come when payment is actually due under the policy. Sending one the day after a loss, before the insurer can investigate, may not count.
- A proof of loss isn't enough by itself. Filing a proof of loss form is part of the claim, but courts have said it isn't the same as a demand for payment.
- No magic words. You don't need special wording, but the letter should clearly say you're demanding payment of a specific claim and that the insurer may face a bad-faith penalty if it doesn't pay.
Send the demand in a way you can prove, like certified mail, and keep a copy. If a lawsuit follows, Georgia also requires the policyholder to mail a copy of the demand and the complaint to the Insurance Commissioner within 20 days of filing suit.
When is a denial not bad faith?
The penalty isn't automatic just because you disagree with the insurer. Courts have held that if the insurer had reasonable grounds to contest the claim, there's no bad faith. A real coverage question, a genuine dispute over the amount, or evidence suggesting the loss isn't covered can all count.
So the statute is strongest when the insurer has no good reason for sitting on a clear claim. It's weaker when the fight is about a close coverage question.
How should you document your claim from day one?
The Georgia Office of Insurance and Safety Fire Commissioner gives claim tips that also help if you later need to prove bad faith:
- Report the loss promptly and write down your claim number.
- Make reasonable temporary repairs to prevent more damage, like tarping a roof, and keep every receipt. Don't make permanent repairs until the insurer has inspected.
- Keep a claim diary. Note the date, time, name and summary of every call.
- Keep copies of everything you send and receive, including photos and estimates.
- Ask for denials in writing. A written denial should cite the specific policy language it relies on.
- Don't rush to settle. If an offer seems low, ask the insurer for an itemized explanation.
What can you do before it gets to a lawsuit?
Most claim disputes never reach the bad-faith statute. A few steps often move a stuck claim:
- Ask the adjuster, in writing, what specific information is still needed and when a decision will be made.
- Ask to speak with a supervisor if deadlines keep slipping.
- Use the appraisal clause, if your policy has one, for disputes about the amount of loss.
- File a complaint with the state insurance office. Its consumer services line is 404-656-2070 or 800-656-2298.
If a large claim is stalled, a Georgia attorney who handles insurance disputes can tell you when a formal 60-day demand makes sense.
Does this apply to liability claims against someone else's insurer?
Generally, no. This statute is about your own policy. Claims against another driver's insurer follow different rules, and Georgia has separate statutes for things like uninsured motorist claims and settlement demands in injury cases. Ask an attorney which rule fits your situation.
What should a demand letter include?
Keep it short and factual. A typical first-party demand lists:
- Your name, policy number, claim number and the date of loss.
- The amount you're demanding and how you got to it, with estimates or invoices attached.
- A clear statement that you're demanding payment and that the insurer may be liable for the penalty and attorney's fees under O.C.G.A. 33-4-6 if it refuses in bad faith.
- The date you're sending it, so the 60 days can be counted.
Many people have an attorney send it, since a defective demand can cost you the penalty.
FAQ
How long does a Georgia insurer have to pay after a demand?
The bad-faith penalty statute uses 60 days after a proper demand for payment on a covered loss.
How much is the Georgia bad-faith penalty?
Up to 50% of the insurer's liability for the loss or $5,000, whichever is greater, plus reasonable attorney's fees.
Is filing a proof of loss the same as a demand?
No. Georgia courts have said a proof of loss alone isn't a demand for payment under the statute.
Can I complain to the state about a slow claim?
Yes. The Georgia Office of Insurance and Safety Fire Commissioner takes consumer complaints at 404-656-2070 or 800-656-2298.
Next step
Start a claim file now with photos, receipts and a call log. If your claim stalls, talk with a licensed local agent about the policy wording, and with a Georgia attorney before you send a formal 60-day demand.
Sources: O.C.G.A. 33-4-6 (Georgia Commons); Georgia Office of Insurance and Safety Fire Commissioner, insurance claim tips.
This is general information for Georgia. It is not a recommendation to buy, drop, or switch a specific policy. Confirm current details with the insurer or a licensed agent who knows your situation.
Agents who publish a lightly edited version on their own domain should set a canonical tag pointing to this URL.
List your business on the Georgia hub, free: Insurance