If an Arizona Auto Policy Is Cancelled: Ten Days to Object, Then the Plan
James Brazil lives in Mérida, Mexico. He founded Swift Agent Sites and studied Classics at the University of Mississippi.
Published · Updated
If you think an Arizona auto insurer's declination, cancellation, or nonrenewal was unfair or illegal, write the Director of Insurance within ten days of receiving the notice. The address on the department's auto page is Department of Insurance, 100 North 15th Avenue, Suite 261, Phoenix, AZ 85007-2624.
After a policy has been in force 60 days, DIFI says the company may cancel only for listed reasons, including nonpayment, fraud, a suspended or revoked license, DUI and other named convictions, and regular commercial use of a private-passenger vehicle. If the policy is already gone and no company will write a new one, DIFI says to apply through the Arizona Automobile Insurance Plan with any licensed property-and-casualty agent. The plan does not change the 25/50/15 minimum.
What are the listed cancellation reasons?
The auto page groups the post-60-day grounds as nonpayment, fraud, license suspension or revocation, DUI and other named convictions, regular commercial use of a private-passenger vehicle, and similar reasons. Read the notice for the specific fact the company used. A notice that only says "underwriting" is the one to quote in the ten-day letter. Keep the envelope so you can show the day you received it.
The ten days are for the objection to the Director. The general complaint queue is a different pace. DIFI says a complaint can wait up to a week before it is evaluated, and filing does not pause a deadline. Send the ten-day letter even if you also open a complaint. See the written complaint. Homeowners nonrenewal uses a 30-day statute that does not apply to the car. See that home rule.
What is the Automobile Insurance Plan?
DIFI describes the plan as the route when the policy was cancelled and you cannot find another insurer. You apply through any licensed property-and-casualty agent. The department does not say the Motor Vehicle Division sells the policy. Bring the cancellation notice, the names of companies that declined you, and the vehicle identification number. Ask the agent whether the application is to the plan or to one more company in the regular market, what limits will be on the binder, and the date coverage starts.
The liability floor for a policy issued or renewed beginning July 1, 2020 is $25,000, $50,000, and $15,000 under A.R.S. 28-4009. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage must be offered. They are not required. The declarations page is the record. See the 25/50/15 minimums. ADOT says you have 30 days after registration to submit proof of Arizona insurance. An application to the plan is not that proof. Coverage starts when the plan or the company says it starts.
What to write in the ten-day letter
Put your name, the policy number, the date you received the notice, and the reason the notice gives. Say why you think that reason is wrong, in a few sentences, and attach a copy of the notice. Mail it to the 15th Avenue address. Keep a copy. If the ground is nonpayment, the letter should also say the date you paid, if you paid, and attach the receipt. A nonpayment cancellation is one of the reasons DIFI lists. Objecting does not, by itself, put the policy back in force.
While the letter is in the mail, ask an agent about a replacement policy or the plan. Driving after the cancellation date without a new policy is the financial-responsibility problem ADOT describes. The card in the car has to match a policy that is still in effect.
What to carry to the agent
Bring the cancellation notice, the vehicle identification number, the registration, and a list of any companies that already said no. Ask the agent to say out loud whether the application is the Arizona Automobile Insurance Plan or another insurer. Ask the effective date and whether uninsured-motorist coverage is being offered in writing under A.R.S. 20-259.01. A quote is not a card. ADOT wants proof of Arizona insurance, and the card has to match a policy that has started. If you are also shopping a homeowners nonrenewal the same week, keep that file separate. The ten-day auto letter does not extend a home policy, and a home repair deadline does not insure the car.
FAQ
How long do I have to object to a cancellation? Ten days from receiving the notice, by a letter to the Director at the address on DIFI's auto page.
Can the company cancel for any reason after two months? DIFI says that after 60 days the insurer may cancel only for the listed reasons, including nonpayment, fraud, license actions, named convictions, and regular commercial use.
Who sells the Automobile Insurance Plan policy? Any licensed property-and-casualty agent can take the application. DIFI does not describe a walk-up counter at the Motor Vehicle Division.
Does the plan let me buy less than 25/50/15? No. Those are the financial-responsibility limits for a current policy. The plan is a way to buy coverage.
Does the ten-day letter pause the cancellation? DIFI says filing a complaint does not pause policy deadlines. Treat the cancellation date on the notice as real until you have a new card.
Next step
Write the ten-day letter the day the notice arrives, and call a licensed agent the same day about a replacement policy or the Arizona Automobile Insurance Plan. Put the new card in the vehicle before you drive. Keep the old notice with the letter you sent the Director.
Sources: DIFI: automobile insurance, A.R.S. 28-4009, ADOT: insurance requirements.
This is general information for Arizona. It is not a recommendation to buy, drop, or switch a specific policy. Confirm current details with the insurer or a licensed agent who knows your situation.
Agents who publish a lightly edited version on their own domain should set a canonical tag pointing to this URL.
List your business on the Arizona hub, free: Insurance